The Toast Lawsuit Is a Wake-Up Call for Every Business Using an All-in-One Payments Platform

By Eric Cohen

Convenience Has a Price Tag. Do You Know What Yours Is?

If your point-of-sale (POS) system, booking software, or industry platform also processes your credit cards, you’re using embedded payments. That can mean fewer logins, vendors, and bills to manage. For a busy owner, that simplicity is genuinely appealing.

But here’s the part most merchants never stop to think about: when payments are bundled into your software, your credit card processing fees get bundled too. They’re harder to see, harder to compare, and much harder to walk away from.

On October 29, 2026, that concern stopped being theoretical. The Federal Trade Commission and eight states sued Toast, one of the largest restaurant tech and payments platforms in the country. Toast strongly disputes the allegations, and nothing has been proven in court yet. Still, the complaint reads like a field guide to the risks every business on an all-in-one platform should understand.

This isn’t a restaurant story. It’s a story about what happens when the company that runs your software also controls your payments, and why you deserve an expert on your side reviewing both.

What the FTC and Eight States Allege

The case, FTC et al. v. Toast, Inc., was filed in federal court in Northern California. The co-plaintiffs are California, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Iowa, Nebraska, Oklahoma, and Utah, according to American Banker. (California joined through the Los Angeles County Counsel and the San Francisco City Attorney rather than its attorney general.) Here’s what the complaint claims, in plain English:

  • The “$0” hardware wasn’t really free. Toast’s Pay-as-you-Go plan advertised equipment at no upfront cost, recovered through a higher card rate. The complaint shows that plan’s basic package at 3.09% plus 15 cents per transaction, versus 2.49% plus 15 cents on the traditional plan. Regulators say restaurants weren’t clearly told about the other costs that came with it.
  • Fees buried in the fine print. The complaint points to an $85 monthly inactivity fee and an early termination fee of $150 for every month left on the agreement, the latter found deep inside a 25-page merchant agreement.
  • Very expensive exits. One owner says he was charged a $5,318.87 termination fee after four years with Toast. Another received an invoice of more than $17,000 after canceling before ever using the system.
  • Add-ons nobody ordered. Merchants describe being billed for subscription features they never agreed to, and still being charged after asking to turn them off.
  • Cancellation by obstacle course. Owners could sign up online but not cancel online. The complaint describes written notice, a weekday-only cancellation line, and multiple internal teams before an account was closed.
  • A fee on diners that went to Toast. From 2021 to mid-2023, Toast added a 99-cent fee to online orders over $10. The complaint says many guests assumed the restaurant charged it, but the money went to Toast, which never refunded it.
  • Loans that discouraged switching. Merchants with Toast Capital loans allegedly needed Toast’s permission to change point-of-sale providers or risked their balance coming due immediately.

Toast’s Side

In a statement, Toast says it strongly disagrees and will vigorously defend itself. Its core argument is that the main federal law involved, the Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act (ROSCA), was written for consumer subscriptions and doesn’t apply to negotiated business contracts. Toast also says it has cooperated with the FTC’s review since mid-2025 and that its restaurant customers negotiate their agreements.

How the court rules on that question matters well beyond Toast. If business software subscriptions are held to consumer-style disclosure and cancellation rules, every platform selling auto-renewing software and payments to small businesses will be affected.

Five Lessons for Any Business Using Embedded Payments

Whether you run on Toast, another POS, or industry software with payments built in, the same dynamics apply. Here’s what we want every merchant to take away.

  1. “Free” usually means “paid for in your rate.” Platforms that give away hardware or software often earn it back through credit card processing fees. According to the complaint, more than 80% of Toast’s 2025 revenue came from financial services like payment processing and lending. That’s not a criticism of the model. It’s a reminder of where the money is made. Using the rates in the complaint, a 0.6-percentage-point gap on $500,000 a year in card sales adds about $3,000 a year in processing fees. The traditional plan carries its own upfront and monthly software costs, so the real question is which plan is cheaper at your volume. That’s exactly the kind of math we run.
  2. Bundling makes fees harder to see. When your software, hardware, add-ons, and processing all live on one statement, it’s tough to tell what you’re actually paying for each. Rate creep or a new monthly charge can blend right in.
  3. Your exit terms are part of your price. Auto-renewal windows, notice requirements, termination fees, and hardware buybacks all determine whether you can ever negotiate from a position of strength. If you can’t easily leave, you have very little leverage.
  4. Fees can reach your customers in your name. The 99-cent diner fee is a warning for any business that relies on a platform’s online ordering or checkout. If a fee shows up on your customer’s receipt, your customer will assume you put it there.
  5. Financing can quietly lock you in. Merchant cash advances and loans from your payments provider are convenient. Read the fine print on what happens if you want to change providers before the balance is paid.

The good news? None of this means you need to rip out your system. It means you need someone checking the math.

Seven Questions to Ask About Your Platform This Week

Pull up your agreement and your last three statements and see how many of these you can answer with confidence.

  • ☐ What is my effective rate (total credit card processing fees divided by total card volume), and has it changed this year?
  • ☐ Does my plan subsidize hardware or software through higher processing fees, and what would alternative pricing cost?
  • ☐ Which monthly subscriptions and add-ons am I paying for, and do I actually use each one?
  • ☐ When does my agreement renew, and how much notice do I need to give?
  • ☐ What would it cost to leave today, including termination fees and equipment?
  • ☐ Are any fees being passed to my customers that I didn’t set or approve?
  • ☐ If I have a loan or cash advance from my provider, does it restrict me from switching?

If you checked fewer than five, you’re not alone. Most merchants never look at their statements, let alone understand how to read them. That’s exactly where we come in.

We Save You Money Without Switching Processors

You chose your platform for good reasons, and you shouldn’t have to tear it out to get fair pricing. Merchant Advocate is an independent advocate for merchants, not processors. We work within your existing relationship, embedded payments included, to make sure you’re paying what you should and nothing more.

Our three-step process:

  1. ANALYZE — We review your statement at NO charge to uncover inflated rates, hidden fees, and coding errors.
  2. ADJUST — We negotiate with the processor on your behalf to reduce rates and eliminate extra fees.
  3. AUDIT — We consistently monitor your statements every month to watch for rising rates and additional fees, to ensure you keep your savings.

We’ve helped our clients save more than $300 Million in excess fees. There’s no upfront cost, you pay Merchant Advocate only when you realize savings.

The Toast case will take time to play out in court. Your statement doesn’t have to wait. Why not have an expert who is on your side double-check what you’re paying? Get a FREE analysis today!

Visit www.merchantadvocate.com or call 732-727-2073 to get started.

This article summarizes allegations in a pending lawsuit. Toast disputes the allegations, and no court has ruled on them.